KBD

Keith Devens .com

Monday, October 6, 2008 Flag waving
Everybody makes their own fun. If you don't make it yourself, it ain't fun -- it's entertainment. – David Mamet (as relayed by Joss Whedon)
← lgf: Yon: On Patrol with the Iraqi National PoliceKartRider →

Daily link icon Friday, November 16, 2007

Surfer dude stuns physicists with theory of everything

Surfer dude stuns physicists with theory of everything - Telegraph (via).

← lgf: Yon: On Patrol with the Iraqi National PoliceKartRider →

Comments XML gif

Ben Karel (http://eschew.org/) wrote:

The danger of reporting on technical subjects by non-technical reporters, for consumption by non-technical (at least in this subject area) readers:

http://arstechnica.com/news.ars/post/200...of-everything-severely-deficient.html

∴ Ben Karel | 17-Nov-2007 1:50pm est | http://eschew.org/ | #10386

Keith (http://keithdevens.com/) wrote:

The problem is that Lisi has ignored much of physics, where he adds normal numbers to vectors and other similar no-nos (imagine adding a speed to an energy and you have got exactly what Lisi has done). He has found that the chosen symmetry operations correspond to the symmetry groups of particles—not that surprising, considering the number of symmetry operations he has at his disposal—but he hasn't checked to see if the masses come out as found experimentally because he can't; once you put nonsense into a model, the only thing that comes out is nonsense.

In the Observatory thread on this topic, posters have pointed to a blog article that puts Lisi firmly in the crank category, which is exactly right. However, New Scientist has to take a good chunk of the blame here by taking something that any good particle physicist can recognize as complete rubbish (it fooled me until I started to look at what his equations actually meant) and turned it (and Lisi) into an anti-establishment star (he's a surfer, not a scientist...).

Too bad. Thanks for the comment.

Keith | 17-Nov-2007 10:23pm est | http://keithdevens.com/ | #10388

Feel free to post a comment below. Please see my comment policy.

Formatting Rules (No HTML):

  • **bold**, *italic*, _underlined_, --strikeout--
  • "text"="url" creates a link, and URLs are auto-highlighted
  • Blockquote: Like e-mail, begin paragraph with > (greater-than sign)
  • Lists: begin paragraph with *,-, or + (unordered), or # (ordered)
  • Code block: ?!code:language=perl|php|sql|javascript|etc.{\n}...{\n}?!/code

:
(will be your IP address if blank)
: (optional)
(Will not be shown on site)

: (optional)
:

October 2008
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
 1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728293031 



RSS feed RSS feed for Keith's Weblog
Atom feed Atom feed for Keith's Weblog
Weblog archive
Recent comments
  on 6 posts

Recent comments XML

new⇒Girls, please don't get breast implants

Makes me sick to hear normal sized​women whining about being small. B​cup i...

Rachel: Oct 5, 7:42pm

obout inc - ASP.NET controls

I like there components. I've got​it to work locally on my pc.​However I'm ...

Jeff: Oct 2, 4:43pm

Dumb substring behavior in C# (and Java)

Yes, the Substring function is not​helpful when you hit the length​problem,...

Mike Irving: Oct 2, 7:56am

YouTube - Burning Down The House: What Caused Our Economic Crisis?

> Please save another copy of the​"Burning Down The House" video as​the ori...

Keith: Sep 30, 11:05am

Johnny Walker Blue Label

I bought a 2 finger glass for 60​bucks about 5 minutes before my​wedding. I...

Ty: Sep 30, 9:52am

More on the bailout

I figured they wanted about a buck​or so from every man, woman and​child on...

Peggy McGilligan: Sep 30, 12:20am

Generated in about 0.121s.

(Used 8 db queries)

mobile phone