Keith Devens .com

What a naive mode of thinking.

Why?

I think it might be possible that many of the things we give thanks for--private property, freedom of the press, freedom of commerce--were recognised by the Plymouth Fathers as direct by-products of the Protestant Reformation. The trajectory of which had something to do with a "theologically significant birth."

Thanks Daniel for pointing this out. Thanksgiving is very much a Christian holiday, though of course a distinctly American one. Who do you think the pilgrims were giving thanks to? Here's an article I read the other day, an excerpt from a new biography of Benjamin Franklin:

The Real Story of the First Thanksgiving
By Benjamin Franklin (1785)

“There is a tradition that in the planting of New England, the first settlers met with many difficulties and hardships, as is generally the case when a civiliz’d people attempt to establish themselves in a wilderness country. Being so piously dispos’d, they sought relief from heaven by laying their wants and distresses before the Lord in frequent set days of fasting and prayer. Constant meditation and discourse on these subjects kept their minds gloomy and discontented, and like the children of Israel there were many dispos’d to return to the Egypt which persecution had induc’d them to abandon.

“At length, when it was proposed in the Assembly to proclaim another fast, a farmer of plain sense rose and remark’d that the inconveniences they suffer’d, and concerning which they had so often weary’d heaven with their complaints, were not so great as they might have expected, and were diminishing every day as the colony strengthen’d; that the earth began to reward their labour and furnish liberally for their subsistence; that their seas and rivers were full of fish, the air sweet, the climate healthy, and above all, they were in the full enjoyment of liberty, civil and religious.

“He therefore thought that reflecting and conversing on these subjects would be more comfortable and lead more to make them contented with their situation; and that it would be more becoming the gratitude they ow’d to the divine being, if instead of a fast they should proclaim a thanksgiving. His advice was taken, and from that day to this, they have in every year observ’d circumstances of public felicity sufficient to furnish employment for a Thanksgiving Day, which is therefore constantly ordered and religiously observed.”

Recently a canadian in Japan was complaining about Thanksgiving in America. I always loved Thanksgiving. 2 days of no work with tons of great food. How can anyone complain about that!